Monique, we just had our 5th wedding anniversary on friday 14 Nov. I was in the same boat, it's so hard to buy for men!
I ended up getting him this gold scroll pendant, our initials engraved on the front and the boys names engraved on the back. He loves it (it was a little bit more sentimental, as I gave him the gold necklace he wears it on on our first wedding anniversary).
I got one of those "Willow" statues - don't know if you've seen them, but I've been collecting them since pregnant with Tyran.
Night all, been so sick today, bad flu, throat so sore I can't swallow properly.... YUK!!